What's It Like to Be a Muslim Woman in America? Street Experiment Explores

NEW YORK, NY - AUGUST 29: A Muslim woman walks in an ethnically a diverse neighborhood in Queens on August 29, 2016 in New York City. Queens County is one of the five most diverse counties in the United States with a large Latino and Asian population among other groups. Immigration has once again become a topic dividing the candidates in the upcoming U.S. presidential election. Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump, who has been an advocate of building a wall with Mexico and deporting all illegal immigrants, is expected to give a speech on Wednesday to clarify his positions on immigration policy. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Source: Spencer Platt/Getty Images News/Getty Images

Here's an interesting video from YouTube star Yousef Erakat, designed to show what's it like to be a Muslim woman in America. Erakat recruited a female friend to dress in a hijab and hit the park for a little social experiment. Playing the part of an American racist, Erakat — a young Muslim man whose mother chooses to wear a hijab — publicly berates the woman for dressing "like a terrorist" and tells her "go home." The goal was to see how bystanders would react and whether people would ignore it or intervene. 

For the most part, they ignored. As Erakat shouts at the veiled woman, ostensibly a stranger to him, the majority of people shown in the video avert their eyes and scurry on by. A few, however, do stop to intervene. "Are you kidding me?" one woman asks, making a beeline for Erakat as soon as she sees what's happening. "It's her choice. You can go f**k yourself." 

After two hours of filming, "our spirits were shattered as only two people came up to us," Erakat writes on the video's YouTube page. But though it's easy to read this video as a damning critique of American apathy or racism or carelessness, I'm not so sure it's that straightforward. We're conditioned in this society to only intervene in other people's affairs when it appears violence is about to occur. It seems somewhat patronizing to expect that this woman can't handle her non-violent heckler on her own — to think oh, this poor Muslim woman, she needs protecting and saving by me! Apparently, my reaction was a common one in the YouTube comments. This was Erakat's response: 

It's appalling how people are DEFENDING the bystanders and blaming it on variables like, "the acting was horrible. no one would believe you." "you are a Muslim why would they believe it?" "if you had hit her people would have done something." ... People are ashamed that no one did anything so are looking for justification as to why the video is flawed and not the people. WAKE UP PEOPLE. They ALL looked back. They ALL watched. They ALL were aware of the injustice. It was their choice to not do anything. I am not trying to put the blame on the people and make America look bad. I am trying to raise awareness as to why it's important to not just watch and walk away. 
Is it as bad as Erakat says? How would you have reacted? 


Must Reads