Joel McHale's 'Comments Section' Has Potential But It Needs to Be Extra Careful

This probably won't be a troll takedown, but it's something: Joel McHale from The Soup and Community has gotten the go-ahead from his show's network to create a new show with presumably a similar format as The Soup, this time tackling internet comments sections. As you may know from being a general human being that exists and interacts with the world wide web, comments sections on any website are strange black holes of hatred and conspiracy theories and pure, dumb rage. But why!? Hopefully that's something McHale's new show, tentatively titled Comments Section and to star comedian Michael Kosta, will tackle.

Comments sections being unhallowed ground is nothing new. In an op-ed last year for the New York Times, contribute Michael Erard tries, pedagogically, to determine what exactly it is that makes comments sections "the most obnoxious development of the Web, the wild back alleys where people sound their acid yawps." What indeed? Chelsea Peretti recently took a crack at taking down comment culture in her new comedy special on Netflix, One of the Greats. In an interview with Vulture about her special, she talks about the distance that people put between themselves and celebrities when deciding to type out something disgusting and press enter with conviction. On talking to a friend about Britney Spears' depression:

My friend was like, “I have no sympathy for her! She’s rich. She’s famous. She has no reason to be depressed.” I think something happens where, if you’re at all in the public eye or making money, people’s sympathy just changes. You become an entity or an object instead of a person. There’s really nothing you can say to stop it.
Michael Kovac/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Celebrities, entertainers and public figures aren't the only victims of insidious comment culture, of course. If you are ever reading any op-ed or think piece about feminism, classism, racism, rape, sexual assault on college campuses, victim-blaming, Bill Cosby, Woody Allen, drone strikes, "Obama's post-racial America," or Ferguson: I urge you, DO NOT SCROLL DOWN. Unless you want to lose whatever modicum of faith in humanity you have left.

That's where I get nervous; the point of Comments Section is to put on blast these ignorant vigilantes all across the web, typing furious vitriol from behind a screen. McHale should be careful, though, with the content of the show; there's no tact in having a show where every episode needs a trigger warning. I'm all for displaying people's ignorant comments on the screen to highlight just how bigoted, absurd and wrong they are, but hopefully the ugliness is contained and monitored.

Image: Getty