After a pandemic-era pause and a sputtering start, Broadway is back (thank God!) and feels bigger than ever. Attendance has reached 95% of pre-COVID levels — and based on photos of people holding up their Playbills that are flooding my social media feeds, that stat rings true.
The most exciting aspect of the season, however, has been enjoying the variety of shows on offer. Plays range from thought-provoking Pulitzer winners (Purpose) to so-funny-you-might-pee-your-pants farces (Oh, Mary!). On the musicals front, you’ve got bold originals bursting onto the scene (Dead Outlaw and Operation Mincemeat), beloved adaptations achieving cult-favorite status (Death Becomes Her), and splashy revivals introducing new audiences to their iconic goosebump-provoking scores (Sunset Blvd.).
For me, the beauty of live theater remains grounded in the fact that it transports you to another universe, allowing you to stay blissfully off your phone for a couple of hours. (Please don’t be that person whose device rings during a dramatic monologue.) Since the first Broadway show I saw when I was 4 years old (Peter Pan — Cathy Rigby stan forever over here), I’ve always loved that the performing arts will challenge you, make you laugh or cry (or both), and have you walk away thinking about the world or yourself in a different way.
None of this would be possible without the Tony Award acting nominees, nine of whom Bustle caught up with ahead of the June 8 ceremony. See how they hammed it up for our cameras, and read on to learn about their theater superstitions, pre- and postshow rituals, and dream roles.
— Christina Amoroso, Editorial Director
Interviews and Photographs: Jillian Giandurco and Katherine Diermissen
Design Director: Emma Chao
Social Director: Charlie Mock
Editor-in-Chief: Charlotte Owen
SVP Creative: Karen Hibbert
Show: Oh, Mary!
Nominated for: Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a Play
Notable previous role: Ninoy Aquino in Here Lies Love
Pre-show ritual: “I always say, ‘Have a great show, f*ck face,’ and then Cole [Escola] says, ‘You, too, f*cker,’ before every single show. It’s just something that started downtown. I’ve been calling Cole a f*ck face for a year and a half.”
Show: Boop! The Musical
Nominated for: Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical
Notable previous role: Gretchen Wieners in the Mean Girls national tour
How she gets into character: “When I’m getting into hair, makeup, and wig. It takes me about an hour to get fully into Betty.”
Show: Just in Time
Nominated for: Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Musical
Notable TV role: Kacey in Sex Lives of College Girls
How she spends off days: “I’ve been playing shows [with my band, Lawrence] on my day off. I flew to Atlanta on one of my days off for a Lawrence show. We keep it busy.”
Show: Dead Outlaw
Nominated for: Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical
Notable previous role: Beau in Shucked
Dressing room essentials: “Toothbrush, toothpaste, floss. You got to be nice to your fellow actors.”
Show: A Wonderful World: The Louis Armstrong Musical
Nominated for: Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical
Notable previous role: Genie in Aladdin
Dream role: “We used to go to the Disneyland spectacular of Aladdin, and I always wanted there to be an African American genie, and then I got to be one — but I got to do it on Broadway.”
Show: English
Nominated for: Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Play
Notable previous role: Mahwish in The Who & The What
Post-show ritual: “Sometimes I need to just literally shake my body and make sure that I’m leaving the character at the theater and take five minutes to meditate when the show is done so I’m not bringing it home with me.”
Show: Gypsy
Nominated for: Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Musical
Notable previous role: Catherine Parr in Six
Pre-show ritual: “Go bother everybody on my floor. I really have adopted this sort of assumed role of annoying neighbor. It suits me, it fits well in my skin, so I take that job very seriously.”
Show: John Proctor Is the Villain
Nominated for: Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Play
Notable previous role: Matilda in Matilda the Musical
Pre-show ritual: “I am majorly superstitious. No whistling in the theater. No talking about the Scottish play. I won’t do any of that. I think that every wrong step I make is going to lead to some butterfly effect of doom.”
Show: Purpose
Nominated for: Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Role in a Play
Notable previous role: Lutiebell Gussie Mae Jenkins in Purlie Victorious
Dressing room essentials: “I have to have everything, like a new pair of socks, just in case. A whole new outfit, a snugly outfit from between shows. So many things.”