Did Governor Cuomo Say Pro-Lifers Should Leave New York? (Hint: Not Exactly)
We can already hear the right-wingers screaming. On Friday, New York governor Andrew Cuomo sat down with Susan Arbetter on "The Capitol Press Room," and made some inflammatory comments about "extreme conservatives." The most salient of these remarks that that conservative citizens who are pro-life or anti-gay "have no place in the state of New York, because that's not who New Yorkers are."
The backlash wasn't helped by Cuomo's criticism of an ideological split within the Republican Party, which, according to Cuomo, pits a camp of more extreme Republicans against the more moderate members of the party.
Here's an excerpt from the transcript of his comments, via Times Union:
The gridlock in Washington is less about Democrats and Republicans. It’s more about extreme Republicans versus moderate Republicans… You’re seeing that play out in New York... Their problem is not me and the Democrats; their problem is themselves. Who are they? Are they these extreme conservatives who are right-to-life, pro-assault-weapon, anti-gay? Is that who they are? Because if that’s who they are and they’re the extreme conservatives, they have no place in the state of New York, because that’s not who New Yorkers are.
If they’re moderate Republicans like in the Senate right now, who control the Senate — moderate Republicans have a place in their state. George Pataki was governor of this state as a moderate Republican; but not what you’re hearing from them on the far right.
We know Cuomo to be a pretty liberal guy: He wants to increase minimum wage even more; is on board with implementing the Roe v. Wade decision into New York law; and recently took an executive action to legalize medical marijuana. But to suggest that the far-Right is unwelcome in his state is a very strong statement, and conservative citizens have not taken kindly to what they perceive to be a request to get out of the Big Apple.
It's not clear if Cuomo is criticizing all anti-abortion, pro-assault-weapon, anti-gay conservatives, or only extreme conservatives who share those views. Though it's well-established that there are cracks in the Republican Party between the unmovable GOP and the party's more moderate members, the distinction between the two factions is not quite as clear-cut as Cuomo suggests.
And you can bet conservative groups weren't amused, either. Dennis Poust, director of Communications for the New York State Catholic Conference, was one of them.
Unsurprisingly, many conservative news outlets omitted the second part of his remark, where Cuomo tempers his statement by saying that "moderate Republicans" do have a place in his state. Other outlets declared that he's against all pro-lifers, ever, The National Review's Kathryn Jean Lopez published an article last Friday titled, "Pro-life? Not Welcome In Andrew Cuomo's New York." And Fox News began their piece on Cuomo's statements like this:
New York Governor Andrew Cuomo believes that pro-life activists along with anti-gay activists, and supporters of the Second Amendment, are not welcome in his state.
Now, some people are taking to Twitter to declare that Cuomo is entirely anti-conservative, and wants non-liberals to leave New York right now.
Cuomo's office quickly released a statement after his remarks sparked ire — in large part thanks to the New York Post article with the headline, "Gov. Cuomo to Conservatives: Leave NY!" According to the statement:
If you read the transcript (below), it is clear that the Governor was making the observation that an extreme right candidate cannot win statewide because this is a politically moderate state (either moderate Republican or moderate Democratic).
In the same response, the Governor went on to say "it is fine" to be anti-gun control, and anti-choice” – as he respects both positions.
And a closer look at the transcript reveals that Cuomo was, on the whole, a lot more reasonable than the headlines would seem.
70% of this state wants intelligent gun control. 'We don’t agree with gay marriage, we are anti-gay,' that is fine but 70% of this state about, is now pro-gay marriage so figure out who you are and figure out if you are of a extreme conservative philosophy and if you can survive in this state. And the answer is no.
Truth: 1. Sensationalism: 0.