Florida Man Learns He's Not A U.S. Citizen — After Decades Of Voting, Serving In The Military, And Working For The Government

JERSEY CITY, NJ - SEPTEMBER 17: A Pakistani immigrant and new American citizen applies for a U.S. passport following a naturalization ceremony at Liberty State Park on September 17, 2015 in Jersey City, New Jersey. The group, representing 30 countries, took the oath of allegiance to the United States on U.S. Citizenship Day. They are part of some 36,000 people that United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) plans to nationalize nationwide during the week of September 17-23. (Photo by John Moore/Getty Images)
Source: John Moore/Getty Images News/Getty Images

If ever there was an indictment of the government’s ability to keep its records straight, this is it. After living in the U.S. for almost 50 years, serving in the Army, casting votes in every presidential election since 1976 and working for the federal government for over two decades, Florida man Mario Hernandez has discovered that he’s not actually an American citizen. He’d gone his whole life believing that he was, and only learned the truth when, during preparations for a Caribbean cruise with his wife, he applied for a passport for the first time.

Luckily for Hernandez, he isn’t in danger of being deported. Cuban refugees in the U.S. aren’t eligible for deportation, and neither are military veterans. But he’s been stripped of the right to vote, and if he ever leaves the country — for example, on a Caribbean cruise — he can’t come back.

“I thought I was a citizen — I’ve always been proud of being a citizen,” said 58-year-old Hernandez. “This has really messed with my head.”

Hernandez came to the country from Cuba with his family when he was nine. Upon arriving in Miami, he was handed a parole document, standard practice for Cuban refugees. At that point, he would have been eligible for U.S. citizenship in five years — but his parents never filed the necessary paperwork. As is, that parole document is the only documentation he has.

And yet, over the last 49 years, Hernandez has voted in presidential elections, paid taxes, and worked for no less than three government agencies, including the Department of Justice. He spent 22 years as an employee at the Bureau of Prisons, and was tasked with keeping watch over numerous high-profile prisoners, including the Oklahoma City bombers. Unsurprisingly, that position required U.S. citizenship, and Hernandez underwent a background check every 5 years; somehow, though the system never picked up on the fact that he wasn’t a citizen. 

In March, he requested U.S. citizenship, but was denied. That case was later reopened, however, and is still pending.


Must Reads