SeaWorld Orcas & Trainers Will Stay Separated, And SeaWorld Just Keeps Struggling
If you've seen harrowing documentary Blackfish, you know why things haven't been going well for SeaWorld lately. Still, the marine-animal theme-park company is trying: SeaWorld San Diego recently agreed to expand its orca tanks so the giant mammals can stretch their fins while in captivity. The company has also thrown its weight behind SeaWorld's orca trainers, denying to appeal a court ruling keeping SeaWorld trainers out of the killer whale tanks. Basically, SeaWorld won't be going to the Supreme Court after all.
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration, an agency under the U.S. Department of Labor, hit SeaWorld with three citations following the death of orca trainer Dawn Brancheau at the Orlando park in 2010 — an incident at the heart of Blackfish. According to the filing, Brancheau was reclining on a platform several inches below the water's surface when Tilikum, an orca responsible for two other deaths, pulled her off the platform. Brancheau suffered traumatic injuries and drowned. (If Tilikum's name sounds familiar, it's because he's the whale at the center of Blackfish.)
Although SeaWorld parks removed trainers from the water following Brancheau's death, the company tried appealing one of the citations, which said trainers must remain behind a barrier when they work with the killer whales. A panel on the U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington, D.C., ruled against the company in April.
The judges concluded:
The Secretary presented evidence that the killer whales posed a hazard in spite of SeaWorld’s safety measures. ... Statements by SeaWorld managers do not indicate that SeaWorld’s safety protocols and training made the killer whales safe; rather, they demonstrate SeaWorld’s recognition that the killer whales interacting with trainers are dangerous and unpredictable and that even senior trainers can make mistakes during performances, and the managers repeatedly urged caution in working with the killer whales. The evidence thus supports the ALJ’s finding that a recognized hazard existed, even beyond the impact of SeaWorld’s safety protocols.
Lawyers representing SeaWorld argued that close human-whale interaction was necessary for the park's business model, but the appeals court believed extra safety measures wouldn't harm SeaWorld.
To be sure, SeaWorld has increased its safety measures for its killer whale trainers over the years. The same month of the appellate court's decision, SeaWorld parks debuted inflatable safety vests for orca trainers, in case they fell or were pulled into the tanks. According to The Associated Press, the five-pound vests inflate like a floating device, and feature small oxygen tanks.
SeaWorld also revealed several other new safety features this spring, reported the AP, including remote-controlled pool gates and special platforms that can lift a whale out of the water in case of emergency.
A lot of people remain unhappy with SeaWorld and its treatment of both the orcas and their trainers. The animal-rights activist group PETA recently bought more stock in SeaWorld, as a means to eventually gain some control over the theme parks and release the killer whales from captivity.
PETA's Lindsay Rajt told San Diego 6:
By buying more stock in SeaWorld, we can continue to push executives toward the only humane solution for the orcas captive and that is relocating them to the coastal sanctuaries.
Not only has SeaWorld's stuck plummeted this year — it fell 33 percent last week alone — but the parks' attendance and revenue is way down across the United States. According to The Chicago Tribune, SeaWorld second-quarter profit of $405.2 million was far below Wall Street's prediction of $445 million.
Trainers may not be able to swim with the killer whales ever again, but at this rate, it's the least of SeaWorld's troubles.
Images: Getty Images (3)