'Project Runway All Stars' Season 4 Cast Ranked From Worst to Best

Try using the arrow keys

As the tagline of the Lifetime reality competition Project Runway goes, "One day you're in, and the next day you're out." Most of the designers on Season 4 of Project Runway All Stars have been on the latter end of that statement, and now they're looking to get back in vogue on the new season premiering Oct. 30.

Yes, 14 of our favorite designers from past seasons of Project Runway are back to win some money and some bragging rights as one of the best up-and-coming designers in America. I was really hoping Season 13's runner-up Amanda Valentine would be invited back for this All Stars season since she was robbed (robbed, I tell you!) of the winning title last season of Project Runway, which wrapped Oct. 23. Alas, filming on Project Runway All Stars probably started before Season 13 ended, but I've already begun my campaign for her appearance on Season 5.

Even without Amanda, we've still got a good group of past contestants returning for one last shot at glory. Among them are winners, runner-ups, and a few stragglers who probably shouldn't have been on Project Runway in the first place, let alone an All Stars edition. So who has the best chance of winning? Take a look at the designers of Season 4 of Project Runway All Stars, ranked from worst to best, according to what they created during their first time on the show.

Image: Barbara Nitke/Lifetime

More Slideshows