18 Singers Who Passed On Recording Some Of The Biggest Hits

It's hard to imagine some of the biggest pop songs being recorded by someone other than their original singer. After all, who could imagine a Lady Gaga or Beyoncé song sung by anyone other than Mother Monster and Queen Bey? But, while many hits may seem tailor-fit to the pop stars who took them into the recording booth, not every song ended up in the hands of the person who was originally meant to sing it. In fact, certain pop stars were the second (and sometimes even third) choice to record a track — even though fans wouldn't be able to hear the song any other way. Click through to read about which singers could have recorded some of pop's biggest hits instead.

by Kaitlin Reilly

"Pretty Hurts," Beyoncé

Believe it or not, this track wasn’t originally intended for Bey. In fact, songwriter Sia sent it out to two separate artists before it landed in Beyoncé’s lap.

Matt Cardy/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Katy Perry & Rihanna

Sia e-mailed “Pretty Hurts” to both the “Dark Horse” and the “S&M” singer, but Perry didn’t see the e-mail and Rihanna’s people turned it down.

Larry Busacca/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Telephone," Lady Gaga feat. Beyoncé

Remember that crazy music video?! Well, it almost didn’t happen — at least, not with Lady Gaga and Beyoncé.

Jemal Countess/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Britney Spears

Lady Gaga wrote “Telephone” for Spears to use on her album Circus, but the song was dropped from the album. Gaga decided to use it years later as a track on her Fame Monster album.

Jason Merritt/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"We Can't Stop," Miley Cyrus

The former Hannah Montana launched her new image with the crazy music video for “We Can’t Stop,” but the song wasn’t originally given to Cyrus.

Frederick M. Brown/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images


According to PopSugar, RiRi was offered “We Can’t Stop,” but decided that she preferred her other option “Pour It Up” better.

Kevin Winter/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Happy," Pharrell

It’s tough to imagine anyone other than Pharrell singing the bubbly tune, but another singer actually recorded his own version that was never released.

Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Cee Lo Green

Pharrell co-wrote “Happy” and passed it on to Green, who recorded his own version. The “powers that be” weren’t as thrilled with the version, and Pharrell ended up taking it into the recording studio himself.

David Buchan/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Since U Been Gone," Kelly Clarkson

The “bye, bye boyfriend” anthem wasn’t originally intended for the American Idol winner.

Ethan Miller/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Hilary Duff

The former Lizzie McGuire star was offered the song, but turned it down, allegedly due to the fact that she couldn’t hit all of the notes. Pink also passed on what would become a hit single for Clarkson.

Dave Kotinsky/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Rock Your Body," Justin Timberlake

Timberlake proved he wasn’t a boy bander any more with this smooth track, but, while it seemed perfect for the singer, it wasn’t originally going to go to him.

Ian Gavan/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Michael Jackson

The Neptunes offered Jackson “Rock Your Body” for his album Invincible, but the singer passed and it went to Timberlake.

Gareth Cattermole/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Umbrella," Rihanna

“Umbrella” was a huge hit for Rihanna, but it could have been one for another pop star instead.

Kevin Winter/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Britney Spears

The song, which was co-written by The-Dream, was rejected by Spears’ label.

Kevin Winter/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"How Will I Know," Whitney Houston

One of Houston’s greatest hits could have been performed by an entirely different artist had she not rejected the track.

Getty Images/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Janet Jackson

Jackson’s team passed on “How Will I Know,” which was excellent news for Houston, who recorded the hit and took it to the top of the charts.

Vittorio Zunino Celotto/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Toxic," Britney Spears

Spears scored her very first Grammy with the sexy single “Toxic,” but it wasn’t written for her.

Frank Micelotta/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Kylie Minogue

The “Can’t Get You Out Of My Head” singer was played a demo of “Toxic” but passed on recording the track.

Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Golddigger," Kanye West

West penned the track, but he didn’t choose to record it until this singer passed on it.

Frazer Harrison/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images


Yep, “Golddigger” was originally told from a woman’s perspective. When Chicago-based rapper Shawnna passed, West rewrote the hook from a man’s point of view and recorded it alongside Jamie Foxx.

Frederick M. Brown/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Battlefield," Jordin Sparks

Sparks wasn’t supposed to pose the question of why love always feels like a battlefield.

Paul Morigi/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images


According to PopSugar, Rihanna’s team turned down the song as it was optioned around the time of her then-boyfriend Chris Brown’s very public assault of the singer, and the lyrics just didn’t seem appropriate. Oddly, Rihanna went on to record the “violence is sexy!” single “S&M.”

Gareth Cattermole/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"...Baby One More Time," Britney Spears

Spears’ first single wasn’t intended for the up-and-coming singer — though it’s tough to imagine anyone else in the music video’s school girl outfit.

George De Sota/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images


The girl group rejected Spears’ single, which means that you can thank TLC for helping turn Spears into the princess of pop.

Jason Merritt/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Call Me," Blondie

Debbie Harry co-wrote the hit and made it famous, but it was originally offered to a different blonde singer.

Karl Walter/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Stevie Nicks

The Fleetwood Mac vocalist was originally offered the track, but decided to pass.

Kevin Winter/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Disturbia," Rihanna

This hit was originally intended for a male voice.

John Lamparski/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Chris Brown

Brown co-wrote the track and planned to record it himself, but once his then-girlfriend Rihanna listened to it, she asked if she could be the one to put it out. He obliged, agreeing that a female vocalist might be better suited for the song.

Andrew H. Walker/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"I Don't Want To Miss A Thing," Aerosmith

Aerosmith may have recorded the sentimental song, but it wasn’t supposed to be a rock band number at all.

Mark Davis/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Celine Dion

Diane Warren penned the tune and allegedly originally gave it to the “My Heart Will Go On” singer, until Aerosmith needed a song to record for Liv Tyler’s film Armageddon.

Andreas Rentz/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Skyscraper," Demi Lovato

Lovato’s ballad worked perfectly with the positive message on her album Unbroken, but it could have gone to a different artist.

Andrew Chin/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Jordin Sparks

Though Sparks passed on “Skyscraper,” she liked the track so much that she took to YouTube to do a cover of her very own.

Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images News/Getty Images

"Halo," Beyoncé

The sweet song off of I Am… Sasha Fierce was written with a different artist in mind.

Ian Gavan/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Leona Lewis

According to reports, the “Bleeding Love” singer was simply too busy to record “Halo,” and the song ended up in Bey’s hands. Both singers could have nailed the vocals, but it’s totally Beyoncé’s song.

Chris Jackson/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

"Don't Cha," The Pussycat Dolls

Before The Pussycat Dolls asked the world whether we wished our girlfriends were hot like them, another singer was asked to record the track.

Handout/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Paris Hilton

Hilton turned down the track before it was picked up by the girl group, later stating that, had she heard it in the form it was recorded, she would have jumped at the chance to sing the tune.

Nicky Loh/Getty Images Sport/Getty Images