'Batman vs Superman's Possible Wonder Woman & the Conundrum of Writing a Feminist Icon

For one of the most beloved — and most heavily discussed — superheroes of all time, Wonder Woman sure has had a dearth of actual live-action appearances in the past... well, in the time since Lynda Carter hung up her Golden Lasso in 1979. But there is the exact opposite of dearth when it comes to talking about Diana Prince and what is and/or isn't keeping studios from having the confidence to bring her back — and not just for a hastily aborted TV show. Recently, it's been rumored that Man of Steel sequel Batman vs. Superman will feature Wonder Woman, and Uproxx paired that news with this very notable recent quote from Carter herself:

Maybe they need a female writer who gets it. I’ve often tried not to say that, but I think it’s the truth. It’s like, ‘Hellooooo guys, get a female that understands what that’s all about.’ You look at any society that suppresses women, and it’s violent. Look around the world. … There’s a humanity that they’re missing. There’s got to be a sweetness, a kindness, a goodness in the character. The rest takes care of itself.

It's kind of a notorious problem in Hollywood that no one can seem to "get Wonder Woman right." Joss Whedon even tried and failed, and he's a man with a pretty impressive track record when it comes to writing complex female characters.

But maybe that's just it: From David E. Kelley's botched Wonder Woman pilot to Joss Whedon's abandoned Wonder Woman feature script, why aren't there more women taking a crack at what is arguably the most famous female superhero of all time? Why not leave one of the most iconic feminist figures in history to be written by, I don't know, a female?

Here's another thing Carter said in her interview with ETOnline:

They miss the point of Wonder Woman. [...] I think they try to just make her a female version of a male superhero, and that’s not what she is.

Is part of the character's problem that she's being bandied around like "a female version of a male superhero?" She's definitely right in that female superheroes shouldn't have to be masculinized in order to fit our idea of heroic.

There are female superheroes for whom adopting aspects of traditionally masculine-associated traits fit more smoothly with the character — Black Widow in The Avengers, for example, mixed a certain emotionally reserved "macho" toughness with a heightened savvy of how to use and manipulate the people around her with the more traditionally feminine of her assets.

Just as with male superheroes, though, this isn't a one-size-fits-all type of thing. Diana Prince is not the same person as Natasha Romanoff, who is not the same person as Wanda Maximoff, who is not the same as Kitty Pryde or Barbara Gordon. Nor should she be.

The argument definitely exists that people might not want a more "sweet" (read: a more traditionally feminine, and therefore associated with weakness) female superhero right now, which seems to be what Carter is pushing for. It might be, though, that when it comes to this particular character, that trait might be one (of many) that lie at the core of the humanity that might be the key to Wonder Woman.

This all reminds me of a quote that regularly circles around Tumblr, originally posted by user Madlori in response to a question about writing ladies:

Screw writing “strong” women. Write interesting women. Write well-rounded women. Write complicated women. Write a woman who kicks ass, write a woman who cowers in a corner. Write a woman who’s desperate for a husband. Write a woman who doesn’t need a man. Write women who cry, women who rant, women who are shy, women who don’t take no shit, women who need validation and women who don’t care what anybody thinks. THEY ARE ALL OKAY, and all those things could exist in THE SAME WOMAN. ... So don’t focus on writing characters who are strong. Write characters who are people.

Basically: We all contain multitudes, and that shouldn't be erased because we're looking for someone kick-ass.

Writing an icon is hard. She's more than a lone person, she is a history. She's one who symbolizes the embattled strength and impenetrable perseverance of second-wave feminism. But to bring her to life in the world we live in now, maybe the key to Diana Prince lies in not catching ourselves being paralyzed by that past, but in thinking of her as a person, and in bringing Wonder Woman along with us into the third wave — with everything that comes with it. Image: DC Comics