Kelsey Poe went quickly from sad widow to villain on this season's Bachelor. I hate to say this about anyone, but she is a strangely unlikable person. Probably because she goes around thinking people don't like her because she "uses big words." But Kelsey was back for Monday's Women Tell All to tell her side of the story, and apologize to some of the girls she'd wronged, which included Ashley I., who she called Kardashian-fake and then said was way beneath her.
It was hella rude at the time, and then Kelsey got in the hot seat Monday and got all pompous about things. "How do you evaluate humanity?” she asked Chris Harrison as a way to get out of the fact that she did evaluate Ashley, and very poorly at that.
Although I do agree with Britt that the women shouldn't joke about Kelsey inventing her husband, I also think they were right in being annoyed with her. Both on the show and at the Women Tell All she was over-the-top with her verbose explanations of why she was so disliked. It's not surprising that many of the show's contestants reacted to her speech with confusion, disbelief, and frustration. Here are 11 of the best faces they made while Kelsey was talking. And they tell a story all their own.
Image: David Moir/ABC
Trina Wasn't Having Any Of It
Homegirl was eliminated super early on, but that didn’t stop her from being annoyed with Kelsey.
Oh No You Didn't!
Trina’s face was my face when Kelsey said the women didn’t like her because, “I use big words.”
You can practically see Samantha thinking, I did not get zero screen time on this season only to be dragged out and made to listen to this.
Not A Friendly Face In Sight
Kelsey’s words of contrition fell upon deaf ears. In short, the ladies didn’t care, and I don’t blame them. Kelsey was pretty patronizing.
Mackenzie Couldn't Remember Why She Was There
I should have just stayed home with my son Kale and watched this on TV, she probably thought while the rest of the ladies listened to Samantha confront Kelsey.
Amber Was So Done
She couldn’t contain her laughter when hearing Kelsey defend her actions on the show.
Ashley I. Was Back For Revenge
The best faces of the night go to Ashley I. who was forced to go on a double date with Kelsey and then watch her tell America that Kelsey was way smarter than Ashley. So it’s safe to say she wasn’t having any of what Kelsey dished out on Monday.
Aw, Hell No!
Ashley wasn’t going down without a fight. She confronted Kelsey about acting superior. Kelsey tried to explain it away. “How do you evaluate humanity?” she asked. Deep.
Ashley’s face here gives me life.
I Mean, Really?
Kelsey’s words literally broke Ashley at this point.
Her Best Jim Halpert
As Kelsey continued to talk, Ashley shot the camera a very Jim Halpert from The Office meta look. Don’t worry, girl. I feel you. And I appreciate you making Kelsey’s segment watchable and relatable.