‘Pretty Little Liars’ Real Life Twins, Because Everyone In The Cast Could Have A Surprise Twin

The major theory the Pretty Little Liars fandom is working on now is that Jason DiLaurentis has a twin. The twin theory has been a popular one for years thanks to the books which feature Alison having a twin. But the show has slipped in several twin references over the years, too. There were the two girls dressed in the same yellow top that fateful night, and the scary Halloween story about the girl who killed her twin, etc.

But whether or not the Jason having a twin theory is correct, it got me thinking about the PLL cast and who their celebrity twins would be. Some of the people on this show look identical to other Hollywood A-listers. Maybe if I. Marlene King decides she needs a twin for any of her characters, she can call on these celebrity doppelgangers.

Image: ABC Family

Mrs. Hastings

Spencer’s lawyer mother has another crime-invested look-alike.

Image: ABC Family

Mariska Hargitay

The woman best known for playing a detective on Law & Order: SVU, looks exactly like Mrs. Hastings. They even chose similar career paths!

Ilya S. Savenok/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Aria Montgomery

The artsy member of the group has an equally artsy twin.

Image: ABC Family

Selena Gomez

Lucy Hale gets mistaken for the singer all the time.

Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Hanna Marin

Hanna’s one-of-a-kind — unless you count the celebrity double she has.

Image: ABC Family

Taylor Momsen

The Gossip Girl star looks just like Ashley Benson, and even has the same kickass attitude as Benson’s character Hanna.


Emily Fields

The swimming star has a pretty famous look-alike.

Image: ABC Family

Naya Rivera

The Glee actress and Pretty Little Liars actress Shay Mitchell look so similar! They’re also friends, which means occasionally they’re spotted out together. And it’s like you’re seeing double.

Imeh Akpanudosen/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Spencer Hastings

Preppy, good-girl Spencer has a Hollywood doppelganger that anyone would be proud to look like.

Image: ABC Family

Rooney Mara

Something about those high cheekbones and pursed lips make both ladies look the same.


Alison DiLaurentis

The sneaky secret keeper also happens to look a lot like one of her own co-stars.

Image: ABC Family

Ashley Benson

My new PLL theory is that Hanna and Alison are related. (Just kidding, but anything can happen in Rosewood.)

Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Melissa Hastings

The eldest Hastings sister has a gorgeous celebrity double.

Image: ABC Family

Eva Longoria

The Desperate Housewives star would fit right in on Pretty Little Liars if the creator ever wants to give Melissa a twin.

Alex Wong/Getty Images News/Getty Images

Caleb Rivers

Everyone’s favorite bad boy turned good has a surprising A-list look-alike.

Image: ABC Family

Johnny Depp

Between the scruff and the hair, these two look the same. But, more so than appearance alone, they have the same rugged attitude towards life.


Ezra Fitz

Aria’s boyfriend has a pretty super celebrity double.

Image: ABC Family

Henry Cavill

The Superman v Batman star could play Ezra any day.

Max Morse/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Toby Cavanaugh

Spencer’s boyfriend has an equally chiseled twin.

Image: ABC Family

Cody Simpson

Those cheekbones though!

Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images

Jason DiLaurentis

If Jason really does have a twin, I. Marlene King can call on his celebrity double to play the role.

Image: ABC Family

Patrick Schwarzenegger

With a little bit of movie makeup, the two celebs could be twins.

Tommaso Boddi/Getty Images Entertainment/Getty Images