Does Clean Sleeping Work? Experts Weigh In On The Latest Goop Trend
Everyone knows the basics of a good night’s sleep: try to get at least eight hours, no snacks before bed, no devices in the bedroom, etc. But in all her infinite wisdom, wellness goddess and Goop founder Gwyneth Paltrow has found a way to kick that process up a notch, through what she calls “clean sleeping.” But does clean sleeping actually work?
In an article adapted from her new book Clean Beauty and published the Daily Mail, Paltrow explains that clean sleeping is the practice of prioritizing sleep above all else. She calls for getting at least eight hours of sleep each night (and ideally 10), and going to sleep every night by 10 p.m.; limiting caffeine intake “to support the gut and adrenals”; exercising regularly (ideally before noon) to “reset your body’s circadian rhythm”; and keeping your bedroom wholly separate from work. Paltrow also advocates investing in a copper pillowcase ($40 on Amazon) to fight off bacteria.
Many of these practices are common sense sleep strategies, just taken to the extreme limit. But many people are wondering if there might be some science behind these claims, especially the ones that go above and beyond the typical sleep advice that we’re used to. Read through to learn about the tenets of clean sleeping, and whether sleep experts think that it works.
Sleep Should Be Prioritized Above All Else
In her original article, Paltrow sets out the fundamentals of clean sleeping. “Sleep plays such a powerful role in determining your appetite and energy levels that I believe it should be your first priority — even before you think about your diet,” she says. While sleep is hugely important for your day-to-day function, experts say don't stress out if you can't always make it a priority. “Society doesn’t allow you to have amazing sleep 100 percent of the time, and have other things you care about in life,” says Dr. Els van der Helm, sleep expert and founder of Shleep, a company that coaches people on how to sleep better for maximum productivity. “If you have 75 percent good nights per month, then I’m happy,” she says.
Get At Least Eight Hours of Sleep Per Night (Ideally 10)
Most experts agree that eight hours is an average of the amount of sleep most people need; the right amount of sleep for the majority of the population will fall in the seven to nine hour range. “There's a really small percentage of people that would actually need 10 hours” of sleep, Dr. van der Helm tells Bustle. “For the rest, it can just do damage.” That damage includes what Dr. van der Helm calls “fragmented sleep,” where you’re waking up a lot in the night because you simply don’t need that much rest, putting yourself in danger of developing insomnia. “The optimal amount of sleep is where you can sleep pretty well throughout the night without spending a lot of time awake in bed,” she says.
Be In Bed By 10 p.m.
As with the optimal amount of sleep, the best time to actually go to sleep is different for everyone. While experts agree that going to bed at the same time every night is best to maintain a normal sleep schedule (and can even have benefits for heart health, too), there’s no reason why that time must be 10 p.m. every night.
An add-on to this rule (and why it's supposedly worth it to go to sleep at 10 p.m., even if it’s not your body’s natural cycle) is that “the sleep between 10 p.m. and 12 a.m. is some of the most restorative,” according to Paltrow. This pearl likely comes from the old wives’ tale that “sleep before midnight counts double,” but that myth has been roundly debunked. Your "most restorative" sleep happens during the first few hours of slumber, according to the Centre for Integrated Research and Understanding of Sleep, no matter what time you go to bed.
Limit Caffeine Intake To Support The Gut And Adrenals
This also qualifies as generally good advice, but the jury is out on the connection between gut and adrenal health and sleep. “There's a huge relationship between sleep and almost every process in your body,” says Dr. van der Helm, “but I don't think the full picture is clear in terms of the science.” If you need a rule to stick to, avoiding caffeine after 2 p.m., and limiting yourself to two cups per day will help you perpetuate your regular sleep schedule, according to the National Sleep Foundation.
Exercise Regularly To Reset Your Body’s Circadian Rhythm (Ideally First Thing In The Morning)
Regular exercise has been proven to help people sleep more soundly for an overall better night of sleep. But as with the best time to sleep, the ideal time to exercise to maximize your sleep benefits is highly individual. Dr. van der Helm says that exercising first thing in the morning would be good advice for a night owl, but for someone whose problem is that they wake up too early, “they should be exercising late in the afternoon.” Exercise is not the only thing that will help reset your circadian rhythm, either; exposure to bright light, through natural light or a sun lamp, will help stimulate the brain to become more alert.
Make Your Bedroom A Sanctuary By Separating It From Work
“Your brain is really good at forming associations,” says Dr. van der Helm; by creating a very clear association of the bedroom with sleep, you can trigger almost a “Pavlovian response” of getting sleepy, according to Dr. van der Helm. Making sure your bedroom is engineered to be a comfortable sleeping environment is a priority. “A dark and clutter-free environment promotes ‘clean sleep’,” Julia Walsh, a certified sleep consultant, tells Bustle. “Keep screens (TV, phones, tablets, etc.) elsewhere.” Apart from triggering an association with work, phones and laptops in the bedroom “emit blue light, which tricks the brain into thinking it is day time, inhibiting melatonin, a natural sleep hormone,” says Walsh. So if you didn’t have a reason to shut your phone off after hours, now you do.
All in all, Goop’s advice isn’t the worst when it comes to getting the best sleep possible, but it’s definitely not going to work for everyone. Each person’s body is different, and has different needs from the next person. But, as Dr. van der Helm put it, “it's about convincing people why they should make a change” in their sleep habits. Prioritizing sleep (even if not over everything else) can absolutely help anyone — from the morning birds to the night owls — feel a difference in their waking life.