The "3 Percent SB" Hashtag Calls Out Super Bowl Ads That Stereotype Women
Even if you aren't much of a football fan, you might choose to watch the 2018 Super Bowl just for the commercials. According to Sports Illustrated, the average advertiser spends more than $5 million on a 30-second 2018 Super Bowl commercial, so the ads are usually pretty good. But during the big game on Feb 4, 2018, #3PercentSB started to trend on Twitter thanks to The 3% Movement, an organization that aims to bring more diversity to the advertising field. I asked myself, "Why is #3PercentSB trending?" The answer is actually pretty simple: People felt like most ads were aimed toward men and wanted to call them out — as well as praise the companies who actually got it right. Per the organization's mission statement: "Only three percent of creative directors are women. And even less are people of color. So we’ve made it our mission to bring that number up to fifty percent."
During commercial breaks, The 3% Movement rated each commercial by what it calls the "3 percent test." The questions: Is there a woman? Is she defying stereotypes? Is she the hero? The organization congratulated advertisers that passed the test, like Lexus, and called out advertisers who didn't, explaining why their ads were problematic. The crux of the viral hashtag is straightforward: Women want advertisers to feel heat if their ads don't feature diversity, and individual callouts are a unique way to do so.
And as Twitter user @Shannon_Mc2 pointed out, not speaking to women is actually a complete waste of money for advertisers, tweeting, "While you watch those #SuperBowl ads today, remember....women are half the audience and 80% of the buying power in the US."
The organization also hosts Super Bowl Tweetups all over the U.S., where female advertising pros get together to live-tweet their thoughts about each commercial. Curious about what they had to say about the commercials that aired during the biggest football game of the year? These are some of the best tweets recognizing companies for their inclusion (or lack thereof) during the 2018 Super Bowl.
1. Why Can't Creative Directors Surprise Us?
Hey, the Eagles surprised us.
2. Justin Timberlake Has More Backup Dancers That Are Female
What's up with that?
3. Calling Out A Lack Of Size Diversity
Where are all the women who aren't a size 0?
4. Congratulating Brands Who Get It Right
This commercial that used gender-neutral pronouns was a win — and hopefully others took notice.
5. Reminding Brands That We'll Remember Problematic Ads
In case you weren't aware, it's pretty obvious when nothing is speaking to us.
6. Throwing Shade At President Donald Trump
Seriously though, where are all the women?
7. Reminding Everyone Of The Real Problem
Unfortunately, this problem is deep-rooted
8. Women Are More Than Half The Audience
Not speaking to women in your Super Bowl commercial is a problem for many reasons — and throwing away your money is one of them.
9. Where's The Diversity?
White, blond, and thin = #NotBuyingIt
10. Not So Much
This face says it all, sadly.
11. Doesn't Count
Nope, robots with women's voices definitely don't count as female representation.
12. Change The Ratio
Think about how many men there are.
13. Tick Tock
Um, we're still waiting tho.
14. It's Scream-Worthy
Not even one.
15. And If You Weren't Already Frustrated AF...
...There's this fact to ruin your night.
16. Remember Us?
Just in case you forgot.
17. A Simple Way To Score More Points
More racial diversity, please.
As user @saatattack went on to explain what explicit diversity versus diversity is: "Where POC show up as the heroes of the story, not just mere sidekicks or tokens. It's not enough to just appear in the story."
And here you have it — the #3percentsb and #NotBuyingIt hashtags certainly made a statement about the lack of representation during this year's Super Bowl ads on social media. And even though it was representing something that is largely problematic in more ads than you may have realized, it's nice to see something like this — among the Half Time Show, details of the game, and that weird brief screen blackout that had everyone making memes — make it's mark on social media during the show. Let's hope advertisers were listening.