12 Famous People You Forgot Were On Millennial Nickelodeon Shows

If you follow millennial protocol by being a little too obsessed with your childhood, it’s a safe bet that you mainline ‘90s Nickelodeon cartoons on the regulars... and sometimes a few early 2000s picks, if you’re getting crazy. And now that you’re older, wiser, and The Splat keeps you updated on celebrity cameos, you may have noticed all the famous people in Nickelodeon shows. Be it tiny before-they-stars celebs, or big name adults that popped by the kid’s channel, it’s an incredible thing.

And we’re not just talking about all Adam West or Tim Curry’s recurring gigs on the channel. Please. If you listen hard to your favorite animated classics, you’ll hear some of your favorite real life voices. And if you even skim the surface of live action favs like The Adventures of Pete and Pete or Are You Afraid of the Dark?, the amount of famous celebs in the mix almost gets absurd. But if you don’t believe me, I paged through YouTubes and found video evidence. Granted, some of them are in serious VHS quality but... hashtag vintage?

Whatever, it should still be a trip. Feel free to scroll down and revisit some of your favorite Nick shows with some unexpected yet familiar faces.

1. Jay Baruchel

Long before he was tainted by a million Judd Apatow products, Baruchel nabbed a few guest spots on Are You Afraid Of The Dark?. In fact, his first real acting credit is attributed to the show, which is no surprise because Are You Afraid Of The Dark? seemed to be a breeding ground for young talent. And, you know, nightmares.

2. Selma Blair

Blair played Big Pete's love interest for an episode... and she played it blonde, which is totally visually confusing.

3. Steve Buscemi

Mark Grabowski on YouTube

Buscemi had not one, not two, but three solid appearances on The Adventures of Pete and Pete playing Ellen's father and Big Pete's guidance counselor. A guest appearance on a Nick children's show is definitely a far cry from HBO (and, you know, a monumental film career), but it feels like a reasonable place to stop by in the early '90s.

4. Neve Campbell

Whaaaat? Campbell and her perpetually furrowed eyebrows made it into a horror TV show? In the '90s? That seems so wildly off-brand for her.

5. Linda Cardellini

Enjoy this little bit of magic from Kenan and Kel: after getting bamboozled by the boys (and some chili?), Cardellini pulls a middle-school-Mary-Grace by screaming she's not a witch. She seems like a lovely orange-soda-loving girl who just happens to wear a bunch of black. Chill, Kenan.

6. Emmanuelle Chriqui

Here's big-time name that got her start on Are You Afraid Of The Dark?, and, on that note, someone else who started from SNICK and moved up to the ultimate after-hours programming of not-TV-but-HBO. With, you know, some stops along the way.

7. Ryan Gosling

hobbyhumoristen on YouTube

Hey girl, you already know this. You've already been waiting for this. Baby Gosling was a guest star on (wait for it) Are You Afraid of the Dark?.

8. Julia Louis-Dreyfus

NickSplat on YouTube

Who would guess that Arnold's illicit teacher crush would turn out to be Elaine Benes?

9. Michelle Trachtenberg

NickSplat on YouTube

Before the days of Buffy and Gossip Girl, Trachtenberg had a few solid gigs on Nickelodeon, playing minor roles in both Clarissa Explains It All and The Adventures of Pete and Pete. And, lest we forget, she was also the titular Harriet in the Nickelodeon produced Harriet the Spy.

10. Alex Trebek

NickSplat on YouTube

The Jeopardy game host really stretched his acting chops here by voicing a mustached game host named Alan Quebec on Rugrats. Bless.

11. Frank Zappa

Michael Bayer on YouTube

Welp. It seems fitting that the exceptionally strange musician had a voice role as the Pope in Nickelodeon's most exceptionally strange role, just... riding on Powedered Toastman's butt. R.I.P., dude.

12. James Van Der Beek

True life: Dawson was Melissa Joan Hart's first kiss. It doesn't get any more '90s than that.

Doesn't this list just make you want to go back and re-watch all this '90s gold? You're welcome.

Image: Nickelodeon