It's crazy to think that for a full decade, debate has raged over whether the original Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory or the 2005 Tim Burton revamp Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is better. Mainly because the answer is the original Willy Wonka, there's no competition, why would you even compare the two like they're equals? HOWEVER, Burton's Charlie and the Chocolate Factory has it's own intriguing brand of weirdness... especially if you take a second glance of it as an adult.
I mean, OK, I was on the verge of adolescence when the film came out, an already jaded 14 year old gothling. And despite plastering a giant Edward Scissorhands poster on my wall and own Nightmare Before Christmas bed sheets, I honestly couldn't get behind this venture at the time. But if you detach it from the OG Gene Wilder film and put it next to more recent Burton/Johnny Depp travesties, it's really not a bad piece of work. Moreover, there's definite nuggets of cinematic gold if you do a bit of digging.
So to celebrate the film's tenth anniversary, here's all the (odd and eyebrow-raising) 14 karat moments from Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.
1. This is a story of an ordinary boy named Norman Bates
2. This shoddy city planning
Who builds a tilted house in the middle of an industrial city?
3. Charlie already shows off his light serial killer vibe
Who builds a factory out of dented tooth paste tops?
4. "It’ll have 100 rooms, and everything will be made out of either dark or light chocolate"
Um. You mean, dark or MILK chocolate? Wonka's supposed to be the most famous chocolatier and he can't even get his chocolates straight.
AND WHO BUILDS A PALACE OUT OF CHOCOLATE?
5. Willy Wonka is pretty outdated when it comes to PR and marketing
Weirdly effective with his methods, because sales go through the roof after posting like three posters, but I HIGHLY DOUBT that Wonka Co. has a social media editor.
6. This doubles for the original, but it makes 0 percent sense that Grandpa Joe would ~magically~ regain control of his legs when Charlie gets his golden ticket
Also I can't believe the BOLD sense of entitlement when it says Charlie needs chaperone and he's instantly like, "I'll go!"
Grandpa Joe is the worst.
7. 2005 in a nutshell
Ugh, velour tracksuits.
8. The loud "NOPE" that occurs during this scene
9. This expression of disgust when Wonka gets hugged by a child
10. Also when Wonka's weird PTSD makes him dry heave in the effort to say "parents"
Depp really tap dances on the intersection of Michael Jackson and Marilyn Manson in this movie.
11. When candy apparently makes good tinder
12. And when this Oompa-Loompa dances with a cocoa bean on his head
My roommate had to point this one out, it is eternally baffling.
13. The absurd size of the Oompa-Loompa
I know they're supposed to be small, but they're scaled down to an uncomfortable size in this version.
14. When Wonka full-on reenacts the "Beautiful People" music video
15. Animal abuse
It's "whipped cream" and Veruca (rationally is like "That doesn’t make sense."
And Wonka's all, "Whipped cream isn’t whipped cream at all unless it’s been whipped with whips. Everybody knows that."
Because he's batshit insane.
16. When Violet starts turning blue and SHE KEEPS CHEWING HER GUM
Omg, this bitch.
17. All of this
18. This shoddy apartment places
Who uproots an apartment building and places it in an icy tundra?
19. Christopher Lee
20. This impressively unsettling hug
I have plans to frame this image and hang it over my mantle.
Images: Warner Bros. Pictures (21)