There are, honestly, few people in the world who were more excited to hear the theory that Zendaya was playing Mary Jane in Spider-Man: Homecoming than I was. There are also few people in the world who were more crushed when Zendaya denied that she was Mary Jane, and her character was subsequently referred to as "Michelle." Listen, I've been lighting a prayer candle that this was all a clever redirect since March 2016, and now this major clue that Zendaya might be Mary Jane (or MJ) has reignited that flame. The clue comes from the mouth of our latest Peter Parker, Tom Holland, when speaking to Bustle's own Anna Klassen and reporters during the film's Atlanta set visit, and it's a lot. Let me break it down for you.
"[Zendaya] is so powerful and so strong-willed that it’s not going to shake her at all," says Holland, of how the actress is handling the race controversy that broke out when the rumor that she was playing Mary Jane first started. "...I feel like our generation is moving past this whole [idea] that you can’t cast someone who’s not of the right race for a character, and I really think we’re breaking through and changing that, and Z is perfect for it."
I'm sorry, what? Zendaya is perfect for what? I can't think of why Holland would comment on the idea that casting someone of a different race than the comic book character is something that Zendaya is perfect for unless she was playing Mary Jane. Spider-Man mythos does feature a character named Michele Gonzales that Zendaya could be playing, but (a) Peter doesn't meet Michele until college for various reasons and this is a high school story, and (b) erasing a Latinx character from the film to replace her with a black character opens up a whole controversial can of worms.
Granted, Michelle is no nickname for Mary Jane that I've ever heard, but if Betty can be a nickname for Elizabeth Cooper on Riverdale — or, better yet, if Cookie can be a nickname for Loretha Holloway on Empire — then I'm totally willing to accept Michelle for Mary Jane. Or perhaps her full name is Michelle Jane Watson or Michelle J. Watson, and her family or her peers call her "Mary Jane" or "MJ." Again, Mary is no nickname for Michelle that I've ever heard, but see above.
But there's more. During the same set visit, co-producer Hauserman Carroll underlined that Spider-Man: Homecoming would be treading new ground in the universe of our friendly neighborhood Spidey, because, according to him, "our goal was not to see what's already been seen." You know what's not already been seen? A black Mary Jane Watson. Especially a black Mary Jane Watson reading books like Human Bondage in gym class and wearing Sylvia Plath t-shirts.
Now, I already found it telling that, when the controversy all started, Guardians of the Galaxy director James Gunn — who also directed Stan Lee's cameo in Spider-Man: Homecoming — responded with a mic drop-worthy statement:
But these new comments are suspicious AF in how open-ended they are. You'd think, if Zendaya wasn't Mary Jane, then Mary Jane herself would have appeared in a trailer by now. Or Marvel Men In Black would have stepped in with neuralyzers to wipe everyone's minds once Tom Holland threw this spark out there. Since that didn't happen, I'm calling this one.
Sure, the fact of the matter is that Zendaya, at least, very definitively said to ET Online in November 2016, “Well, I’m not Mary Jane unfortunately," when asked about the rumors (that still leaves the MJ loophole in contention, however). And the fact of the matter is that Zendaya is listed as Michelle on the IMDb page for the film. But the real fact of the matter is that, at an Atlanta set visit, with the film nearly finished and the spoilers about to run free, those involved in the movie think her character is breaking racial barriers — despite the fact that she had two lines collectively in the last two trailers and hasn't even been given a last name.