Whether you prefer Chicago- or Detroit-style, the best deep dish pizza pans come in a variety of materials and shapes. The right pan for your home will depend on the type of pizza you want to make, but regardless, it should heat dough evenly and release the crust easily when it's ready.
If you're well into your search, you may have already discovered that some of the most common materials are carbon steel, stainless steel, aluminum, and cast iron. Carbon steel works well in terms of heating up evenly, but it requires extra care to prevent it from rusting. Stainless steel is sturdier and more budget-friendly, however, it does tend to burn crust more easily. Aluminum is another affordable option with an impressively short heat time, and while it won't rust, it is susceptible to corrosion if not cared for properly. And cast iron is a heavy-duty material that can lend a rich flavor to your pizzas, however, it will also require careful maintenance to avoid rusting. Whichever material you choose, keep in mind that dark-colored pans are more likely to burn crust than light-colored pans.
In addition to material, you’ll also want to consider the type of pizza you want to make. If Detroit-style pizza is something you prefer, you'll want a square pan that can create an airy, light center and a crispy crust. For Chicago-style pizza, you'll need a sturdy, round pan that won't buckle under the weight of your creation. And if you're trying to please multiple palates at once, consider a set of mini pans, so everyone can have their pizza just how they like it.
I’ve put together a list of options to help guide your pizza-making decisions. Read on to find the pan that's best for your needs.
1. The Best Carbon Steel Deep Dish Pan
Dimensions: 14 inches (diameter) by 1.5 inches (height)
What's great about it: Made out of sturdy carbon steel, this Chicago Metallic deep dish pan has a nonstick coating that you can count on to successfully release your pizza after baking. While you can put this pan in the dishwasher, it's recommended by the manufacturer to hand-wash it for a longer lifespan.
What fans say: "Yes please! Best deep pan I’ve ever owned. Heat distribution is very even and what a breeze to clean! If you like to make deep dish pizza this is a must!"
2. The Best Aluminum Deep Dish Pan
Dimensions: 14 inches (diameter) by 1.75 inches (height) exterior
What's great about it: Durable, easy to clean, and made in the U.S., this pure aluminum deep dish pan will never rust. It features superior heat conductivity and a reinforced rim that prevents warping. Just be sure to note that this one is hand-wash only.
What fans say: "You can make a great deep dish pizza with this that will be amazing. It was delivered promptly and made a pizza that everyone enjoyed."
3. The Best Cast Iron Pan
Dimensions: 17 inches (diameter) by 2 inches (height)
What's great about it: Pre-seasoned with vegetable oil, this Lodge seasoned cast iron skillet is a versatile deep dish pan that can provide rich flavor to your pizzas. It's ergonomically designed with two handles for ease and security when you're removing it from the oven. To best preserve this pan, it should only be hand-washed without harsh detergent and then immediately dried. You also may need to re-season it periodically.
What fans say: "I absolutely love this pan because of the everyday handles. I can get more on top of the stove or in the oven because of the handles. I use cast iron for almost all my cooking, even pies and pizza. Makes crusts beautiful and brown."
4. The Best Square Deep Dish Pan
Dimensions: 10 inches by 14 inches by 2.5 inches
What's great about it: For those who enjoy making Detroit-style pizzas, this Detroit Style Pizza Company pan is ideal. Made out of steel, it's super sturdy and designed to be nonstick, thanks to a nontoxic coating made from a canola oil blend. This pan is probably best for those who are more seasoned at-home pizza-makers because its dark color can easily burn the crust and it requires diligent care. In fact, you should never wash a Detroit-style pizza pan with soap and water.
What fans say: "As a former Detroiter living on the West Coast it's impossible to find the Detroit style pizza here. This pan is awesome and makes perfect Detroit style pizza. I love that it came pre-seasoned and ready to go."
5. The Best For Individual Pizzas
Dimensions: 7 inches (diameter) by 1 inch (height)
What's great about it: For those looking to make individual, customized pizzas, this Chicago Metallic deep dish set is a great buy. Made from carbon steel, these pans will bake pizzas quickly and evenly. Each pan's perforated bottom ensures a crispier crust, too. However, since a smaller pizza will bake more quickly, you'll want to keep a close eye on it to avoid burning. Like the other choices on this list, these pans should be washed by hand.
What fans say: "We bought these so we could have a pizza party. The idea was that everyone invited could make a pie of their choice, the party was a huge success. The pans are heavy weight, but not too heavy and very durable."
Bustle may receive a portion of sales from products purchased from this article, which was created independently of Bustle's editorial and sales departments.