Why Did The Original Aunt Viv Leave 'Fresh Prince'?

Warner Bros. Television

OK, so we all got super excited by the Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air reunion that Alfonso Ribeiro shared with the world last Monday via his Instagram. And it was truly heartwarming to see the cast still looking so tight knit and friendly after all these years. However, the reunion also stirred up a strong response from Janet Hubert, who played the original Vivian Banks. In a lengthy Facebook post, Hubert stated that she had "no interest in seeing any of these people on that kind of level" and said that "there will never be a true reunion of the Fresh Prince." To understand why she'd be making those statements, you need to know why the original Aunt Viv left Fresh Prince.

After three seasons, during which time Hubert was indisputably phenomenal on the show, the actor was mysteriously replaced by someone else. For another three seasons, until Fresh Prince eventually ended, Aunt Viv was played by a different actor (Daphne Maxwell Reid). At the time, Hubert's sudden absence from the show and replacement was thought to be attributed to creative differences. But, wow, the actual story of why Aunt Viv was replaced on Fresh Prince is so much bigger than that.

Warner Bros. Television

Since the controversial change of Aunt Viv happened in 1993, Hubert, Will Smith, and Ribeiro, have all spoken out regarding the decision, and their own version of the events surrounding it. The year that it happened, Smith addressed the controversy on an Atlanta radio station with some less than favorable statements, claiming:

I can say straight up that Janet Hubert wanted the show to be 'The Aunt Viv of Bel-Air Show,' because I know she is going to dog me in the press. She has basically gone from a quarter of a million dollars a year to nothing. She's mad now, but she's been mad all along. She said once, 'I've been in the business for 10 years and this snotty-nosed punk comes along and gets a show.' No matter what, to her I'm just the Antichrist.

Meanwhile, Perez Hilton reported that, in 2009, Ribeiro did a stand up set in which one of his jokes revolved around Hubert being replaced on the show, claiming:

You know, legally I'm not allowed to talk about it. But hey, why not? ...Long story short, and there were days when we were all on the set and she would literally go off on people and they got to a point by the time the second season came around where we're like, 'This is unacceptable.' We felt like, when we were doing 'The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air,' that we were a family… She, at that point, ruined that, and she made it very difficult for us to work, and unfortunately she was then fired. They brought in Daphne Maxwell-Reid, who we absolutely loved, and we moved on.

All these claims certainly make it sound as though Hubert may have been difficult to work with. However, according to Hubert, there was plenty more happening behind the scenes that was, perhaps rightfully, provoking whatever behavior had annoyed her co-stars.

In January 2016, Hubert posted a (since deleted) Facebook video in response to Jada Pinkett-Smith's decision to boycott the Oscars. In it, she discussed her version of events of what exactly seemed to cause such a feud on the Fresh Prince set, and it sounds as though she was frustrated with Smith for not doing more for the supporting cast. She claimed,

I seem to recall 26 maybe seven years ago, whatever it was. I seem to remember at option time coming to you and saying, ‘You know, Will, you’re the star of the show, why don’t we all get together with you and maybe we could get a little raise. Maybe the network — since the show is such a hit — and you being the star of the show, your influence would help us greatly, like they did on 'Friends,' like white shows do. Remember that?

That definitely puts things in a very different light. If Hubert's statements are true, then her frustrations are understandable, and behavior is given a little more perspective. Regardless, we may never get to the absolute truth of what exactly happened on the Fresh Prince set to have provoked such a strong reactions from Hubert and the rest of the cast. All we have are their varying sides of the story.

For now though, it's clear that there was a clash of personalities that went far beyond simple creative differences, and that perhaps weren't resolved in the friendliest manners. Whatever the truth is, I, for one, will continue to adore the original Vivian Banks forever.