6 Historical Inaccuracies In Disney's 'Pocahontas' — But That Doesn't Mean You Stop Painting With All The Colors Of The Wind
To me, all movies require at least some suspension of disbelief to be enjoyed, and Disney animated films are the rule, not the exception. And though fans of Disney are used to going along with talking-animal sidekicks, it was a little harder to swallow Disney significantly changing the history of Pocahontas for its 1995 movie. Pocahontas turns 20 years old in June, and the animated classic is a still a favorite of mine — hello nature-friendly songs like "Just Around the Riverbend" and "Colors of the Wind"! But even though I was a fan, I understood that Disney took some significant liberties with a real-life historical figure when it chose to Disney-fy Pocahontas.
Of course, history buffs knew the story of Pocahontas long before Disney made a movie about it, but, once the animated movie hit screens, those same buffs were enraged that the film perpetuated historical inaccuracies and romanticized the legend (as in, it literally made the legend romantic). A lot is also not known about Pocahontas — she lived over 400 years ago — and there are many different accounts. But according to the written history of her life on the website for Historic Jamestowne, which is part of Colonial National Historical Park, Disney definitely didn't stick to history's script.
According to the Historic Jamestowne website, Pocahontas's name was Amonute, although she also had the more private name of Matoaka. The name Pocahontas was a nickname meaning "playful one" and Disney did stay true to her playful nature. She was also her father's favorite child and though Disney doesn't show her having any siblings, she is clearly loved by her father in the film. Other than some basic facts though, the movie then diverges from history.
I will always love the film Pocahontas and sing Pocahontas's songs whenever I see a waterfall or go kayaking, camping, or hiking (seriously — every. time.) and I do think the film inspires children to care about nature and accept others. But here are all the ways that Disney changed the real story.
1. Her Age
Pocahontas is said to have been around 10 or 11 years old when she met Captain John Smith in 1607, according to Encyclopedia Britannica. The Historic Jamestowne website wrote that Smith was 27 years old at the time (the real Smith was sans dreamy blonde hair and piercing blue eyes) and the Disney film bumped Pocahontas's age up significantly to go the romance route with the two historical figures. The film did get it right that her father was Chief Powhatan (whose real name was Wahunsenacawh) and that her birth mother was no longer around — historians can't prove if her mother had actually died or not though.
2. Meeting John Smith
In the film, John Smith and Pocahontas meet almost instantly after he lands in America — with the exception of a quick musical interlude with the song "Mine, Mine, Mine." (History does not indicate any spontaneous singing.) In truth, Pocahontas and her father didn't meet any British people for a few months, according to the Historic Jamestowne site. Smith and the British landed in the spring and she didn't encounter Smith until he was captured in the winter by Powhatan's brother Opechancanough. The film was correct in portraying Smith as a well-traveled explorer and soldier and the Colonial Williamsburg Journal confirmed that he traveled to Virginia around 1606/1607 and did work with a man named John Ratcliffe. And Encyclopedia Virginia wrote that Smith came to America from England with the Virginia Company of London, so the details of the opening song "The Virginia Company" weren't far off from the truth.
3. The Romance
Because of the aforementioned age difference, there was no real romantic relationship between Smith and Pocahontas. They were close for a couple of years though since Pocahontas acted as a liaison between the British and the Powhatan Chiefdom. A fact that continued to come up when I was researching their history (particularly on the Historic Jamestowne website) was that young Powhatan Indian children wore little or no clothing (with maybe an animal pelt in the winter). This is an indication that she would have most likely been naked when she met John Smith. For me, this reinforces the idea that Smith probably did consider Pocahontas just to be a child in this new land he had traveled to. So no make-out sessions between the pair went down around Grandmother Willow. Shockingly, history has no record of a talking willow tree — or spunky raccoons and hummingbirds — either.
4. Relationship With Kocoum
In the film, Chief Powhatan wants Pocahontas to marry the stoic Powhatan warrior Kocoum, even though Pocahontas is resistant. Kocoum was a real person who existed, but he wasn't killed by the bumbling British man-boy Thomas like the film shows. The Historic Jamestowne site said that Pocahontas married Kocoum in 1610 ("Should I marry Kocoum?"), a year after Smith left Virginia. Not much is known about Kocoum — an Englishmen's account called him a "private captain," but he could have been a member of the Patawomeck tribe or a bodyguard to Powhatan. (The latter is what the Disney movie kind of went with.) Pocahontas may have agreed to marry him out of love since she would have had the choice to pick who she would marry and he wasn't a high ranking person in the tribe. After her marriage, the National Women's History Museum wrote that Pocahontas was held captive by Captain Samuel Argall in 1613 as ransom since relationships with the Powhatans and British had deteriorated. At that time, the Historic Jamestowne site said that Kocoum was either killed by Argall, or he just assumed he was divorced from Pocahontas (which wouldn't have been an odd event based on their culture) when it was revealed she'd be marrying the British man John Rolfe.
5. Saving John Smith
How John Smith is saved in the movie closely resembles Smith's account of events, according to the Historic Jamestowne website. He wrote that he was brought before Chief Powhatan and forced to put his head down on two stones after he had been captured by Powhatan's brother. A warrior had raised a club to smash his head, but Pocahontas (yet again, let's remember she was probably 11 years old) came and put her head on his to stop him from being executed. The Disney movie portrays Pocahontas placing her head atop Smith's to save him, but the circumstances of his capture were around the fact that he was taking the fall for killing Kocoum. Encyclopedia Britannica wrote that it has been debated whether Smith's account was just made up or perhaps the incident was a Powhatan ceremony that meant Smith no harm. Either way, the Historic Jamestowne site said that Smith was accepted by the Powhatan people and considered part of the tribe after this event.
6. John Smith's Return To England
The National Women's History Museum wrote that Smith left Virginia and returned to England due to a gunpowder wound, but not until 1609 — two years after meeting Pocahontas. In the film, the wounded Smith returns to England after Pocahontas saves him. In real-life, Pocahontas and Powhatan were told he died on his way to England, which was not true. Encyclopedia Virginia wrote that Pocahontas ended up meeting up with Smith when she went to England in 1616. According to Smith's book, The Generall Historie of Virginia, New-England, and the Summer Isles, Pocahontas was emotional upon discovering he wasn't dead and she wanted to call him "father" since her father had welcomed him into their tribe as a son. (Smith wrote that she said, ". . . you called him father being in his land a stranger, and by the same reason so much I doe you.") Yet again, history shows how odd it is that Disney would make Smith and Pocahontas romantically linked.
Pocahontas's story was continued by Disney in the straight-to-video Pocahontas II: Journey to a New World (which I totally rented at a video store as a child), but that movie also appears to be inaccurate. The National Women's History Museum wrote that Pocahontas became ill with tuberculosis or pneumonia while on a ship to go back to America with Rolfe in 1617. She died shortly after at the age of 22 years old and is buried in England. Her father died within a year in America, according to the Historic Jamestowne site, and the relationship between the British and the American Indians worsened and never really improved with the "Peace of Pocahontas" (as it is called) ending.
In 2008, historian and writer Alex von Tunzelmann for The Guardian gave the film a B entertainment grade and a D+ history grade. And that's how Pocahontas is best looked upon two decades after its release: More than above standard entertainment (I'd even say it's great entertainment thanks to the songwriting by Steven Schwartz) — and not a reputable history lesson. But that doesn't mean you can't embrace the adventurous and compassionate spirit of Pocahontas forever since there are much worse ways for her to be remembered.
Images: Disney; Giphy (7)