One of Hannah B.'s Bachelorette contestants may be getting down on one knee a lot sooner than this season's finale. In a season preview that aired on Monday night, host Chris Harrison approaches Hannah and lets her know a someone is there with a ring and ready to pop the question. However, we don't actually see the mystery man who's so convinced Hannah is his future wife. So who proposes to Hannah on The Bachelorette? Is it a remaining contestant or someone who barges back into the mansion? Does she say yes? Why does she seem so upset by the idea? Bachelorette fans have a million questions, and there are a few different ways this situation could play out.
As Harrison makes Hannah aware of the situation, which he says will "change everything," footage of men ranging from Mike to Peter roll onscreen, hinting that it could be one of them who's about to ask Hannah to marry them. But Hannah's reaction to the news makes things confusing: she's not happy, but is instead shown crying, and says that she's "obviously struggling. "Things would've been so different if he wasn't here right now. I don't know what to do, and I'm scared."
So which man could possibly elicit such a perplexing reaction? First off, there's Mike, who's shown in a suit on an elevator certainly looking like he could be about to propose. However, he seems like a great catch — he's previously opened up to Hannah about some pretty serious parts of his past, but he's also proved he can be goofy and silly. Plus, though he's made clear he doesn't have a problem with confronting the other men, he doesn't seem like the type to disrupt the regular process by proposing out of nowhere, and he definitely doesn't seem like the type to upset Hannah so much.
There's also Garrett, who's shown gussying up in the mirror during the ring tease and looking pretty sharp in a suit. He looks like he's ready to do something big, and from what we've seen of him so far, he does appear pretty smitten by Hannah. But again, he doesn't seem like the kind of guy to make such a drastic gesture, or to elicit such a negative response from Hannah.
And the same goes for Peter. In the trailer, he's shown staring solemnly into the distance, looking like someone straight out of the Bachelorette season finale. But while he and Hannah have forged a pretty strong connection, it would be out of character for him to suddenly propose weeks early, or for Hannah to be so distraught by it.
So who does that leave us with? Twitter is convinced it can only be one man: the one, the only, Luke P.
Luke P. has already been asked to leave and ignored that request, so it's not far from the realm of possibility that he'd do it again — and up the ante. Only time will tell if this is the correct theory, but it certainly seems like the most likely one.