Being a Birchbox subscriber, I have a few random samples I’ve received in my monthly boxes, and have been relying on them until I decide to branch out into the mascara world again. Frugality is a must in my life, so I’ve held back on purchasing all the new mascaras coming out this fall. They also have come in handy for this experiment!
Hack #1: Heating Up My Eyelash Curler
I’ve heard this trick a dozen times, from makeup gurus to Pinterest. The idea is that heating your eyelash curler helps lashes stay curled longer. The concept makes sense, since heat helps hair curl or straighten the hair on your head, and eyelashes are also hair, right? The process is simple and only requires an eyelash curler and a heat source, followed by the usual curling technique you use. For this hack, I used my trusty Shu Uemura curler and a hair dryer to warm it up before curling each eye.
I only warmed it up a little because the skin around your eye is very sensitive and I did not want to burn my lashes or eyelids, obviously. Even though normal curlers/straighteners for hair get extremely hot, eyelashes don’t need intense heat and you could actually hurt yourself if you placed something very hot in that area. I heated mine up for a few seconds with the blow-dryer and tested it out on my hand until I felt it was OK to put near my eye.
I am fairly lazy with my everyday makeup routine, especially when it comes to mascara. My hands are just not steady enough to apply it without poking myself in the eye or getting marks all over my eyelids. But this hack seemed to play to that strength for once, calling for wiggling your mascara wand for better eyelash lift. I had heard of this method as the “right way” to apply mascara, since it will also make sure your lashes stay de-clumped and look fuller, but I had never actually tested it out. All you have to do is wiggle the applicator at the roots of your lashes and quickly pull up. This allows for most of the product to be at the bottom of your lashes, instead of the top, making sure your lashes aren’t weighed down with product. It made sense, so I decided to give it a go.
I used W3LL PEOPLE Expressionist Mascara and paired the hack with warming up my curler, as I didn’t think it would hurt the results. I curled my lashes first, and then quickly applied the mascara from the roots to tips once. After seeing the results, I did it once more. I don’t really use much product on my eyelashes, so going over them twice was a lot for me. They looked wonderful directly after I did the steps, but looked just as flat at the end of the day as the first hack.
Hack #3: Applying Mascara While Curling Lashes
This trick was a new one, and I didn’t really understand how it was supposed to help the lashes stayed curled, but I gave it a go anyways. The steps seemed simple enough that all you had to do was curl your lashes and apply your mascara at the same time. However, I am not ambidextrous in the slightest, so after attempting to hold the curler with my left hand and grab the mascara applicator in the other, I ended up with mascara all over my eyes, curler, and fingers. It actually took me multiple attempts to even get myself to apply the mascara, as I kept dropping things and felt like I might accidentally rip my lashes out while I shifted around trying to keep everything in control. It was not easy to do at all, and the end results looked as if I didn’t apply any mascara to my lashes.
Maybe my lack of finesse with doing this hack correctly affected the results, but even before the end of the day, I already knew they wouldn’t be curled beautiful. By the time I got home to take photos, they were pretty flat. This hack was just not worth the trouble, in my opinion. I used Rimmel's Kate Moss ScandalEyes.
Hack #4: Waterproof Mascara Before Regular Mascara
For some reason, I’m not a fan of waterproof anything. Maybe its the chemicals or hydrophobic stuff in the product that scares me, especially because its going to be close to my eyes, but I have avoided waterproof makeup for years. However, so many of the suggestions for keeping eyelashes curled longer is to apply waterproof mascara before regular mascara. According to the gurus, makeup sites, and even the professionals, this is the right way to keep your lashes looking fabulous all day. So, for the purpose of this experiment, I went out and purchased The Falsies Volum Express Waterproof Mascara by Maybelline.
I then went ahead and applied the waterproof mascara, using the wiggling method, followed by a coat of Benefit’s Roller Lash.
At the end of the day, I was impressed by how the curl had held throughout my normal activities. Even though I'd been hesitant to use waterproof before, I may have converted after seeing the results of how it kept my long lashes from drooping over my eyes. It could have also helped that both my mascaras keep my lashes curled, but I'm going to go with the waterproof as the actual reason this hack totally rocked.
Hack #5: Curling Lashes In Parts To Hold Curl Better
Based on my fail at applying mascara with a curler, I was very nervous about trying this technique. How could I curl lashes in sections to get a better curl if I could barely curl them one way? I tend to be heavy handed, so I knew I was going to have to be extra careful doing this in order to not rip out my lashes. I started by curling them how I usually would, then moved the curler over a different section of hair until I was near the tips. I did this process twice to make sure I curled them well, but I was gentle when squeezing the curler just in case.
After doing this, I wanted to make sure the curl lasted longer, so I applied only one coat of Benefit's Roller Lash. By the end of the day, they were still pretty curled, though not as good as the waterproof technique. I did like the results of this hack, but having to carefully curl my lashes in sections made me nervous that I would accidentally crimp instead of curl.
Hack #6: Getting Them Done Professionally
I am, by no means, a professional makeup artist. So, I wanted to see if their magical techniques would make a difference in keeping my lashes curled better than all the hacks I tried myself. The day before Halloween, I was invited to get my makeup done at MAC, so I took the opportunity and spoke with a few MUAs there on their ideas for keeping eyelashes curled.
All of them reminded me that, like any kind of hair, a curl can fall out over time. Regardless of how well you style them, eventually the curl will not be as nice as it was when first styling. Of course, for hairstyling, we have the luxury of hairspray, but applying that to your lashes does not seem like a good idea. However, they reiterated that using waterproof mascara helps keep curls longer, especially using it alongside a curler. After a quick chat, they dolled me up and used False Lashes Extreme Black. My MUA did not use a curler.
At the end of the day, I was still impressed with how the lashes looked. I wasn't able to take a Keek video before my phone died, but managed to snap a few pictures. My lashes still had length, thickness, and a curl better than when I did not use waterproof mascara.
After trying all the hacks, it's clear that waterproof mascara is definitely a must for those looking to hold their curls longer. I mixed and matched most of these hacks (except for the #3) and found that using waterproof mascara always outdid any other attempt when I didn't use it. It is like the hairspray for eyelashes!
Regardless of how you curl your lashes — in parts, with a warm curler, or a spoon — finalizing your look with some waterproof mascara will definitely keep your lashes looking stellar longer. Oh, and it doesn't hurt if the mascara is also good for curling.
Images: Author's own.