#SolidarityIsForWhiteWomen Has Nothing to Do with Hugo Schwyzer, Everything to Do With Listening
What is #SolidarityIsForWhiteWomen about?
Here's how it started: The "retired" self-proclaimed "male feminist" Hugo Schwyzer used to write for feminist blogs from xoJane to Jezebel, but quit after the years of "standing up to women's anger" had "destroyed his mental health." Right.
When Schwyzer called out a black woman who had criticized him, and no white feminists came to her defense, well-known black writer Mikki Kendall tweeted this:
But Hugo Schwyzer is not the point. In fact, as they said in as many constructions as they could muster, continuing to talk about Hugo-Schwyzer-as-catalyst gives him far too much credit, and distracts from the wide-ranging, deep-running set of concerns these feminists of color are airing under its auspices. Conley explained:
I really want to get back to the point: Women of color are doing work. We are doing work in the classrooms, we are doing work online, we have been doing work online. We're doing work in various media platforms. And one thing I like about this hashtag is it allows us to have these conversations: the women who are actually doing the work... I just don't care about Hugo. I don't. I don't want this conversation to be about Hugo. I want this conversation to be... where women across all spans, where trans-folk, where people of all classes can have a conversation.
And the tweets marked with this hashtag have become quite the conversation, though Conley says the dialogue must stretch beyond social media, asking "How are we going to facilitate a space where multiple voices are allowed to speak up, and not be condemned for it?"
How do we facilitate that space? These social media-based feminists are asking self-proclaimed white feminists to engage with the content of this conversation, which will demand self-reflection on the structures of power that already exist. Conley has some ideas for would-be feminist allies: "There is power — there is — in silence."
So what is #SolidarityIsForWhiteWomen about?
Image: Mikki Kendall
Correction: The original version of this story stated that Jill Filipovic was Hugo Schwyzer's editor at Feministe. Fillipovic has not in fact edited Schwyzer.