'AHS: Freak Show' Freaks Aren't Good People, So What's Ryan Murphy Trying to Tell Us?

Watching this season of American Horror Story has been a bit of a trip — and not just because the first four episodes saw a town tormented by a killer clown with a decaying lower jaw, a woman walking around with two Sarah Paulson heads, Elsa Mars as a dominatrix whose legs were sawed off during a porn shoot, and Denis O'Hare's character walking softly while carrying a very big stick. AHS: Freak Show is a bit perplexing, because while we see Evan Peters' Jimmy Darling screaming "we're people!" when Jupiterians treat him and his fellow Elsa Mars' freaks poorly, the series also fails to paint most of the freaks as good people. And if the freaks aren't good people across the board, it makes me wonder what AHS: Freak Show is trying to tell us.

Of course, looking for meaning in a Ryan Murphy show is never easy. AHS: Coven, which seemed poised to teach us lessons about racism, confused everything greatly when it made Kathy Bates' infamous racist murderer Madame LaLaurie somewhat sympathetic (even Gabourey Sidibe's Queenie had a soft spot for her). Glee tried to teach us that the nerdiest, most persecuted kids on campus were often the kindest, best people you could ever meet... and then completely unraveled that promise with every episode after Season 1. But no matter how successfully Murphy gets to his point, he always seems to start out with one.

Freak Show's point seemed obvious enough: Freaks are people too. The initial trailer showed Peters' Jimmy Darling screaming at a car full of Jupiter, Fla. residents who were tormenting him and his show mates and the entire idea that a show called Horror Story would employ a bevy of freaks begged us to question our notions of just what "freaky" really means. I assumed we'd find a Glee-esque blanket appreciation for the good people of Elsa Mars' revue, but instead, it seems that few characters with enough lines to assess are all that good.

Can We Find a Truly Good Freak?

AHS certainly isn't making it easy to find the goodness under the big top. Going through the roster of freaks with the biggest parts, it would seem that shining, pious faces are nowhere to be found, even in our best candidates:

Elsa Mars

  • Was wronged when a group of men sawed her legs off during a boudoir film shoot. + 50 points for sympathy
  • Made her submissive customers sit on a toilet of nails when she played dominatrix. -5 points
  • Suggested Bette stab Dot after Dot sings a killer rendition of "Criminal." -20 points
  • Did it because she's still mourning her own singing career. +5 points
  • Performed on Halloween even though she knew Edward Mordrake would show up and kill one freak when she did. -75 points
  • Gives Freaks a home in an unwelcoming environment... so she can make money and hog the spotlight. +25 points

Goodness score: -20 points

Dot

  • Killed her mother because she wanted to go to the movies. -50 points
  • Tells Bette not to masturbate. -10 points (for lack of sexual health, sheesh)
  • Thinks everyone is going to hell. -10 points
  • Wants to get separation surgery that could kill her sister, doesn't seem to mind the consequence. -100 points

Goodness score: -170 points

Bette

  • Attached to her murderous sister. -20 points by association
  • Stabbed her sister for murdering their mom. -20 points
  • Heavily considers Elsa's suggestion to stab her sister out of jealousy. -20 points
  • Is sympathetic because her sister is so mean and permanently attached to her. +40 points

Goodness score: -20 points

Jimmy Darling

  • Really, really good at sex, which is a gift from God. +50 points
  • Killed a cop and covered it up. -50 points
  • Did it to save Bette & Dot. +50 points
  • Jimmy tried to frame an innocent man for killing the cop. -30 points
  • It was Dell. +10 points
  • But it caused Dell to frame Meep & Meep died in jail. -20 points
  • Felt so bad he turned to the bottle and is generally pretty tortured. +10 points

Goodness Score: 20 points

Even Jimmy Darling, who is arguably the best person we can find on this show (aside from the folks who say nothing and are therefore innocent until proven otherwise) doesn't come out looking all that great. Then you look at the could-be baddies — people like angry Dell, untrustworthy faux-freak Maggie Esmerelda, and 13-inch penis-wielding Stanley the Freak Hunter are all clearly teetering towards the villain side of things. Desiree's not bad, but she does seem to be a bit of a jerk. Even Meep senselessly ripped the heads off of cute little baby chicks (OK, that's a stretch, but baby chickens!). And then there was the time the entire freak show participated in an orgy that was also a potential rape.

So, if finding a truly good freak is so difficult, what the hell are we supposed to take away from this outlandish landscape?

The Answer Is Simpler Than It Seems

Think about the people you know in your everyday life. While none of them have likely murdered someone or made a decision that led to someone else's death or cackled at the potential rape of a mean but still innocent woman, they've probably done something bad that they lived to regret — something as simple as hurting the feelings of someone they love or wronging a coworker in the name of their own success. If we take away the outlandish and horrific wrappings of the Freak Show's Horror Show, we have a group of people who — just like any other people you might know or meet — have done, thought, and contemplated regrettable things. Does that make them bad people? Not necessarily. But should they be held up on a pedestal as the most shining examples of golden, glorious personhood? Probably not.

And that makes things tough on television. Experience has taught us that in the realm of entertainment, persecuted peoples worthy of our affection and understanding are sympathetic and covered by a blanket definition of what it means to be "good." How could anyone be mean to this character? They're so good! Don't people understand that they're good and good people shouldn't be laughed at or persecuted? Cue outrage.

The problem with that pattern is that it suggests that someone who is different is only worth being treated like a human because they are good. By that logic, a persecuted person who is not good should not earn the right to be treated like a person. By that logic, difference or freakishness can only be overlooked when some form of good outweighs a freakish quality. By that logic, humanity is only doled out to those who have earned it through deeds. But spoiler alert: that's now how humanity works.

We're Missing The Real Point Of The Freaks

Giphy

I don't think showing how good freaks are is the point of delivering a cast of protagonists, villains, and anti-heroes who are all "freaks." So, while Freak Show is confusing, it's not failing. By telling a story in which 98 percent of the characters fall under the "freak" umbrella and fall in various spots along the good/evil spectrum, Murphy and Brad Falchuk are forcing us to understand one very simple, very important thing: Freaks are just humans.

Images: Michele K. Short/FX (3); Giphy