Entertainment

Why It's Surprising 'A Dog's Purpose' Is So Sad

by Johnny Brayson

The new film A Dog's Purpose looks like the saddest movie ever made. Just listen to this premise: A dog is reincarnated multiple times throughout the film to love and serve different humans, which suggests viewers will be subjected to multiple heart-wrenching dog deaths. One dog dying in a movie is always a tough watch, but several? Forget it. The movie sounds like it's based on the type of paperback you might find in a drugstore checkout line, but in actuality, is A Dog's Purpose based on a book?

Your suspicions are correct, the movie is indeed based on a book. The novel A Dog's Purpose was released in 2010, and it spent a full year on the New York Times Bestseller List. Given the tear-jerking nature of the book, you'd think that its author, W. Bruce Cameron, was well-known for producing this type of work, but you couldn't be more wrong. The writer is actually best known as a humorist, and his previous work includes the how to parody book 8 Simple Rules For Dating My Teenage Daughter, which was very loosely adapted as the '00s sitcom of the same name starring John Ritter and Kaley Cuoco — and later, David Spade.

Cameron wrote another how to parody book in 2004 called How to Remodel a Man. This one instructs women on how they can mold their male counterparts to their liking by teaching them stuff like how to get men to change the toilet paper roll; explaining to them things like why men own tools; and other wildly hilarious and original takes on gender issues. The book has been featured on Oprah, but surprisingly has not yet been optioned for a sitcom starring Tim Allen.

The movie version of A Dog's Purpose looks to follow the novel pretty closely, and given the book's success, that's no big surprise. And that means lots of tears and not many laughs.

The Pop Culture Briefing You’ll Actually Read
From celeb drama to can’t-miss premieres, Bustle Daily delivers your essential pop culture fix every weekday. It’s the inside scoop on everything everyone will be talking about.
By subscribing to this BDG newsletter, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy