As a fire sign ruled by confrontational Mars, Aries is all about in-your-face color, like M.A.C.’s cream lipstick in the shade red — a vivid, bright bluish-red with a satin finish. “You like lipstick that says ‘I am here and you will listen to me,’” Garbis says, so the brighter the better.

Taurus — a sensual earth sign ruled by the planet Venus — enjoys sexy, natural, your-lips-but-better vibes. To get this look, try one of the Velvet Blur lipstick balms from Simihaze Beauty, which come in a range of gorgeous neutrals. Try Mist, a subtle peach with brown tones.

“Gemini is loud and vibrant and a little bit different,” Garbis says. It’s why you’ll enjoy experimenting with anything trendy and out-there, like metallic lipstick. If you’re in the market for a new shade, go for Grapesicle from Fashion Fair — a shimmery purple lippie that comes in a fun gold tube. Wear it at night or just to the grocery store.

“Cancer likes to be simple yet sexy,” Garbis says. “This would be the sign that would go with a classic berry stain that can be applied regularly throughout the day.” To get a naturally flushed look, go for the cult classic Benetint Liquid Lip Blush & Cheek Tint. Pat it onto your lips, cheeks, and across the bridge of your nose for a sun-kissed glow.

“Leo is go big or go home,” Garbis says. As a fire sign, you like to turn heads wherever you go, whether it’s the office or a family picnic. And what better way to do that than with Pat McGrath’s uber-saturated MatteTrance Lipstick? Opt for the brightest, boldest shade, like the hot pink Extravaganza.

You like to be taken seriously, Virgo, which is why you feel best in practical, wearable makeup. “A Virgo would like perfectly lined lips shaded with a nude matte color,” says Garbis. Try Huda Beauty’s matte lipstick in Staycation, a cool-toned muted beige. Swipe it on for lips that make you feel put-together and ready for whatever comes your way.

As an air sign ruled by Venus, Libra loves to follow a trend, says Garbis. Whether it’s lavender lipstick, glitter glosses, or metallic finishes, you like to have them all in your makeup bag. And yet, you always come back to a classic blue-red, like Fenty Beauty’s liquid lipstick in The MVP shade — your ride-or-die.

As a water sign ruled by Pluto and Mars, Scorpio tends to give off dark, moody vibes, says Garbis, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you want to wear black lipstick every day. For just a hint of mystery, pick up the TikTok-famous Clinique Black Honey — a sheer, glossy lipstick that delivers a gorgeous wash of plum pigment.

When you put on lipstick, Sagittarius, you like to put on lipstick. As a fire sign, you like people to notice you, notes Garbis. “Sagittarius is another one of those bold signs who like an outrageous pop of color where they cannot be missed,” she says. To stun at your next get-together, opt for a deep berry à la NARS’ Try It On Lipstick in Impulse.

When you leave your apartment, you leave for the entire day and get sh*t done. To see you through, go for a long-wearing lipstick in a neutral yet sultry shade, like Makeup By Mario’s Ultra Suede Lipstick in the color Amanda. This deep plum looks great on everyone — and it stays put.

As an air sign, Aquarius is always ahead of the fashion game, says Garbis, which is why you knew about the quiet luxury trend long before everyone saw Sofia Richie’s wedding makeup. You’ve been wearing coral lipstick for months, but if you’re looking for a new shade, try Dior Addict in 659 Coral Bayadère.

To match your makeup to your whimsical water sign ways, go for a soft, beachy pink, like Glossier’s G Suit in Pilot. Slick it on to frolic in the park or walk along the shoreline — and have yourself a daydream. As Garbis says, “The pink will perfectly accent your rosy cheeks and deep, all-knowing eyes.”