J.K. Rowling Commented on Johnny Depp's 'Fantastic Beasts 2' Casting & Her Fans Are NOT Happy
Ever since the first photo from Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes Of Grindelwald was revealed, fans have been urging J.K. Rowling to comment on Johnny Depp's casting as the film's title character. Many wanted to an explanation as to why Depp, whose ex-wife Amber Heard accused him of domestic abuse during the couple's 2016 divorce, was chosen to appear in the film. Now Rowling finally has commented on the Grindelwald casting on her own website, but fans are not happy with the way she's addressing the allegations. (Rowling's rep told Bustle this is the only comment she will be making on the matter.)
Rowling tweeted, "I'm saying what I can about the Grindelwald casting issue here," and shared the link to her post on her website, which shortly after sharing went down "due to maintenance downtime or capacity problems." But in the short time it was live for all to see, a fan pulled a segment of Rowling's message, which read:
The same fan tweeted, "So basically Johnny Depp told you he didn't do it and you believed him. This is sh*t, JK Rowling."
So basically Johnny Depp told you he didn't do it and you believed him. This is shit, JK Rowling.— (@jillpantozzi) #
In Rowling's open letter to fans about Depp, which she later shared on Facebook, she wrote that stories about the actor's alleged domestic abuse "deeply concerned me and everyone most closely involved in the franchise." (Depp ended up agreeing to a $7 million settlement in his divorce with Heard. A joint statement released to TMZ by the two actors claimed that Heard planned to donate the money to charity and that "there was never an intent of physical or emotional harm.")
Rowling also said and that the creators of the film did discuss re-casting the role of Gellert Grindelwald, which was introduced in Fantastic Beasts and Where To Find Them. Ultimately, they decided not to. It's a decision Rowling knows some will not understand, but she closed her note with a message to those who disagree:
That explanation didn't sit well with fans, who questioned how she could so easily support the actor. "The Harry Potter franchise is something so meaningful to me and the other actors are amazing," one fan tweeted. "I am just sad and disappointed that they brought an abuser. I can not agree with that."
@Im_not_Homer @JOC_190 @YoungeArsenal @jk_rowling I am really gonna need it. The Harry Potter franchise is something so meaningful to me and the other actors are amazing. I am just sad and disappointed that they brought an abuser. I can not agree with that.— (@brunarafagnin) #
Another fan agreed that Depp being part of the film sent a bad message to those who have spoken out against sexual abuse.
"He's an abuser. And what's his punishment?" the fan asked. "Being part of a big movie, in a big caracter [sic], because they keep protecting him. That's why the fans don't want him as Grindewald, we don't want abusers being protected anymore."
@caseimz333 @jk_rowling He's an abuser. And what's his punishment? Being part of a big movie, in a big caracter, because they keep protecting him. That's why the fans don't want him as Grindewald, we don't want abusers being protected anymore.— (@izascaramuza) #
Other fans agreed that the decision to keep Depp on the film was another way that Hollywood protects powerful men. Something the industry claimed it would no longer do in the wake of sexual harassment and assault allegations against Harvey Weinstein and others. (Weinstein's rep previously denied all allegations of nonconsensual sex in a statement to the New York Times).
"Instead of facing repercussions he get paid millions bc they keep protecting him," someone wrote. Another person tweeted, "I can’t focus on fantasy and lose myself in a world that a self-admitted abuser is occupying."
@HayliNic @pamstucky @jk_rowling wow this is a bad take. she deserves scrutiny on adding johnny depp as a part of the HP franchise because he's an abuser & instead of facing repercussions he get paid millions bc they keep protecting him— (@nilamatodaria) #
@jk_rowling I still don't see what would have been wrong with keeping Colin Farrell. I'm sorry but I can't in good conscious support this decision. I can't focus on fantasy and lose myself in a world that a self-admitted abuser is occupying.— (@mschelseareed) #
This message comes a week after a fan alleged Rowling blocked them on Twitter after they asked her about Depp's casting. But, Rowling isn't the only person from Fantastic Beats who has publicly come to Depp's defense in recent days. The film's director David Yates told Entertainment Weekly last month, "I can only tell you about the man I see every day: He’s full of decency and kindness, and that’s all I see."
According to Deadline, Warner Bros released a statement of their own earlier today, which echoed much of what Rowling had said:
The question now is will fans continue to support Fantastic Beasts with Depp in a leading role. Judging from Twitter right now, the answer might be "no."