Cancers are known for the shell they retreat to for safety. If that isn’t enough evidence that Caners hate the spotlight, then consider that they’re ruled by the moon, the planet governing our private life and emotions. Cancers are opposite of Capricorn in the zodiac wheel, meaning they juxtapose the earth sign’s need for recognition in the public eye. “Cancers are natural nurturers and feel more comfortable taking care of other’s needs, versus having all the attention on themselves,” says Ater.

Over-thinking Virgos tend to keep a lot to themselves. While it may seem like their type-A personality would command the spotlight, you can think of the pragmatic earth signs as the stage directors and editors. They shine when it comes to logistics and details. “The sun rules Virgo’s 12th house of privacy,” Ater says. The sun shining on your subconscious self “could indicate a need for privacy,” she says.

Scorpio’s lethal pincer has a purpose, and it’s to keep out anything and anyone that threatens its security. Ruled by Pluto, the planet of secrets, murder mysteries, and black magic, the passionate water sign is often called the dark horse — which is why they purposely dodge the limelight. “They often don’t mind showing up as a leader in their career, but when it comes to everyday living, they may shun the spotlight because they value their privacy,” Ater says.

While leading a revolution excites an Aquarius, they’d rather operate behind the scenes than at the forefront. As the oddball of the zodiac, they take on the lone wolf archetype. The sun opposes Aquarius. Essentially, the sun’s bubbly energy is exiled here, giving Aquarius their reputation as an ice queen. “As humanitarians, Aquarians rather have attention focused on the collective versus themselves,” explains Ater.